Showing posts with label Chains. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chains. Show all posts

Monday, 26 April 2010

The Minor 4 Chord (pt.1)



"your song sounds like this"

Time to take a look at a classic Beatles Chord progression. One of the interesting things that Lennon & McCartney did in a majority of their songs was use at least one chord that didn’t belong in the key.

The minor 4 for instance (written like this – iv).

1 Minute theory lesson


(skip it if you know what a minor 4 is)

In major key you have 3 major chords built on the 1st 4th and 5th degrees (I, IV, V) of the scale.

In C that would give you C F G.

In the key of G that would give you G C D.

These all fit together rather nicely (you could even say blandly). But what many Beatles songs do is introduce the minor 4 chord (iv) as well as the major 4 (IV) so you’d have C F G and Fm in the key of C or G C D and Cm in the key of G. These particular minor chords don’t really ‘fit’ and sound a bit ‘spicy’.

1 minute musical history lesson


The Beatles didn’t invent this. They probably stole it from the rock n’roll subgenre called doo-wop. Here’s a typical doo-wop chord sequence

G  G7  C  Cm
G  D7  G  D7

You can hear the progression from IV to iv to I in the bridge of Devil In Her Heart

C I’ll take chances  
Cm for romance is  
G so important to me

and it also pops up right on the end of the fade out of Chains.

A word from Macca


Paul McCartney called going from C & F to Fm “the normal thing [to do]” 
(Many Years From Now p122).

So try using it this week. You don’t want your songs to be abnormal do you?

(Here’s the chord in some popular keys)

E A Am B 

G C Cm D

A D Dm E

C F Fm G

D G Gm A

Read pt 2 - major 4 to minor 4
Pt 3 - minor 6 to minor 4
Pt 4 - minor 2 to minor 4 
Pt 5 - 1 to minor 4

Join the mailing list to get the free, exclusive, Beatles Songwriting Academy podcast!



Friday, 26 February 2010

The Please Please Me Cover Versions




What stands out from the collection of covers on Please Please Me is how little motivation the Beatles got from their cotemporaries to be great writers. In 1962 Bacharach and the other tin Pan Alley/Brill Building composers were writing little more than standard doo-wop numbers like Baby, It’s You, Motown’s ‘golden period’(’64-’69) was still a few years off, Dylan was knocking out folk covers and Brian Wilson was just a three chord surf bum. Songs like Anna (Go To Him) and Chains give no inspiration to rise above the most basic level.

The other thing apparent is what a hard rocking live band they must have been. Boys and Twist And Shout have an energy and drive that is remarkable.


Ronald still hadn't plucked up the courage to tell Clay he wasn't a natural born Isley Brother...

The Isley Brothers' song Twist And Shout is probably the best known Beatle cover and rightly so. Tight as an Emo’s jeans, raw, raucous and recorded live in one take (as was Ringo's feature Boys). The song is notable also for the iconic ending, the ascending chromatic triplets finishing with a ringing D9 chord on the 3rd beat of the bar.

Tickets To Write

Ticket 18 - We've already noted the Beatles habit of finishing on a single ringing chord. The preceeding ascending (chromatic) triplets also appear elsewhere so I'm calling them Ticket 20. A cool end but taken all together such a well known Beatlesism that it might be hard for anyone else to get away with using it.

(And the ending IS a Beatles creation - the Isley Brothers' single fades out).